Quantcast
Channel: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets
Browsing all 21 articles
Browse latest View live

Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

How much trouble would that be to do?  And the estimated cost.

View Article



Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

A few thoughts:- "Graf Spee" only had a 4-inch belt (and she was better armored than either "Deutchland"/"Lutzow" or "Adm. Speer"), most IJN heavy cruisers only had a 3-inch belt.- Having nine 6-inch...

View Article

Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

I think the CA concept was that of a mini BB or BC.After the USN built the Brooklyn's they never went back to just building CA's.  The Cleveland's and Baltimore's came about at the same time.The IJN...

View Article

Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

That should have been 'would it have been a big job'.

View Article

Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

Well the range wise (6 inch vs 8 inch) this really depends on the specific systems. I can't say that the Soviet 152/57 (B38) had any range issues.

View Article


Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

Force H: One thing to consider: RN 6" only has CPBC and HE rounds (8" has SAPC and HE). And the armour of both German CA/PBBs and IJN CAs are probably proof against the 6" round. (Real damage to AGS...

View Article

Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

I still stand by my earlier post. PS I like the Des Moines class. I bought three 1/2400 from the Viking Forge Yards last April. lol This last four weeks has seen some of my worst typing in years

View Article

Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

6" could punch through the armor of most treaty cruisers. I think, yes, 9X6 would have been more useful than 6X8, just as the US found the Brooklyns and Clevelands more useful than their heavies.

View Article


Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

6 inch guns make a far better escort ship too - to ward off those pesky destroyers from presious capital ships.

View Article


Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

BTW, was HMS "Exerter" a ship that tried really, really hard?

View Article

Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

As I stated somewhere, it's been a bad month for typing. Could be the unprecedented amount of CD's I bought in that time period uh Is York a Peppermint Pattie?

View Article

Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

US, Russian, KM, etc - all but RN - 6" guns have a AP round. But RN only has CPC (later CPBC) round. And CPBC round can be stopped by 60mm of armour. So, most Treaty cruisers are armoured against RN...

View Article

Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

'And when HMS York is laid down, the issues with triple turrets' The premise takes place after the triple turrets come about and no hindsight was used. It's about what would the problems be swapping...

View Article


Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

Did the RN's 6 in guns lack AP shells for some technical reason, that is they couldn't make them or an operational reason, like they felt they were superfluous?

View Article

Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

The navweaps site states that the CPBC round could penetrate 76mm of armour at 11000m. Historically both Ajax and Achilles archived one armour piercing hit each. Ajax disabled a secondary and Achilles...

View Article


Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

emc: RN had a SAP projectile for the 5.25", so I wouldn't think it was a technical reason. Appears to have been operational - CLs were supposed to fight armour opponents.. klixrulz: 6" rounds from...

View Article

Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

  "IJN CAs have 100+mm belts; KM PBB (AGS) have 80mm belt; RM (Zara class) have 100-150mm belts. To have to get to within 11km to start to be able to penetrate an enemy CAs belt; when they can...

View Article


Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

Thanks. That's answer I was looking to get. This another one of those questions I should have stated "just out of plain curiosity." What are you doing with the 6 - 8" twin mounts? If I don't...

View Article

Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

The answer to Japans large cruisers?

View Article

Re: Exerter/York With Triple 6" Turrets

Force H: I never was one to take well to instruction, so haven't done 3 forward/3 aft. Initially, I pondered how do I get such a ship within treaties - then inspiration - CB HMCS PEI (Canada's...

View Article
Browsing all 21 articles
Browse latest View live




Latest Images